Case Study
Retro-commissioning of Three (3) Marriott Hotels, PG&E Territory
Enovity recently completed building retro-commissioning at three Bay Area Marriott Hotels. The retro-commissioning work was partly subsidized by the $7.2 Million 2004-2005 CPUC Statewide Building Tune-up Program and project construction implementation was contracted to Enovity directly by the Marriott Corp. The three hotels included the Downtown San Francisco (Moscone Center) Hotel, the 2nd Street Hotel and the Marriott Hotel at the San Francisco Airport in South San Francisco. With a heavy focus on building automation systems (BAS) technology, we helped the Marriott optimize their energy systems while facilitating incentives for the installation of measures that improved building operations, comfort and energy efficiency.
Activities included scoping audits, equipment assessments, pre-functional checks and spot measurements, sensor calibration checks, monitoring plan development, point trending and stand-alone data logging, review of BAS programming, functional testing, and detailed energy calculations. Enovity provided construction management for selected sites and self-performed measure implementation at the two San Francisco hotels. Project deliverables included a scoping audit report with measure energy savings estimates and project cost, a retro-commissioning plan, a monitoring plan, and project implementation reports. Total combined measures savings for all three Marriott’s were $326,700 annually, with 2,668,400 kWh in electricity savings, and natural gas savings of 61,800 therms. Total project cost is approximately $458,700, resulting in an overall payback of less than 2 years. Measures for sites include:
Retrofit exit signs with LED bulbs, de-lamp over lit areas, new high efficiency lighting- Change economizer settings and repair actuators to enable additional “free cooling”
- Schedule fan coils operating hours and temperature setpoints
- Operate staff kitchen hood and make up system only when necessary
- Cooling tower optimization, reset condenser water temperature, reset hot water temperature
- Optimize domestic hot water heaters, boilers and chillers control sequence
- Install CO sensor in garage and modulate exhaust fan with a VFD
- Install VFD for domestic cold water booster pumps to control domestic water pressure
- Install a water side economizer, optimize cooling tower and heat exchanger operation
- Install guest room programmable thermostat with occupancy sensor setback control
- Install VFDs on condenser water pumps, fountain pumps, secondary hot water pumps, VAV air handlers, centrifugal chillers, exhaust fans
- Implement supply air temperature reset for corridor air handlers
- Enable both cooling tower VFD fans to run together at reduced speed to meet load
- Integrate lighting controls with BAS air handler schedule
- Retrofit restrooms with occupancy sensors and meeting room with high efficacy
